PHILADELPHIA – A Delaware County attorney of over 40 years who returned to his duties as a public defender after suffering a stroke, says he was fired from his role this year due to his age and disability.
Leigh B. Bechtle filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania on Nov. 19 versus Delaware County, of Media.
Born in 1949 and after a successful tour of duty in the U.S. Navy, Bechtle says he graduated cum laude from Ohio University and earned his law degree from Widener University School of Law. He was admitted to the Pennsylvania Bar I 1979.
“For the next 35 years, his practice was devoted to defense litigation and trial work. At the age of 65, plaintiff opted to serve in the public sector. He became a full-time assistant public defender with the Public Defender’s Office upon being hired in or about August 2014. A few weeks after plaintiff began his duties he suffered a stroke,” the suit states.
“Plaintiff spent six weeks in Bryn Mawr Rehab Hospital where he received physical therapy, occupational therapy and speech therapy to regain the use of the left side of his body. Aside from enduring, significant impairments in using the left side of his body, the stroke has impaired his speech due to partially paralyzed vocal cords. Notwithstanding these multiple, significant impairments, plaintiff successfully handled courtroom duties for the PDO’s Juvenile unit.”
In February 2020, allegedly due to a complaint from one or more judges who said he could not understand Bechtle, the plaintiff was abruptly transferred into the Appeals unit.
Bechtle says there was no effort made to accommodate him or utilize technology so that the complaining judges could understand him.
“After the COVID-19 related office shutdown, the new Director, Christopher Welsh, fired plaintiff on or about Aug. 17, 2020 for fabricated reasons. Welsh told plaintiff that two memoranda he had recently completed were ‘bad, and below the standards he was hired to uphold,” per the suit.
“Prior to discharging plaintiff, Welsh had expressed disdain for older attorneys in the office. During his short tenure, Welsh has also terminated the employment of other older attorneys for no apparent or legitimate reason.”
Bechtle avers he had no prior warnings, disciplines or corrective actions, his Appeals unit supervisor issue had concerns or criticisms of plaintiff’s work, or of the memoranda he prepared, and his career had featured published writings, contrary to the criticism he received from Welsh.
For violation of the Rehabilitation Act, Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and Age Discrimination in Employment Act, the plaintiff is seeking the following reliefs:
• The County being enjoined from maintaining its illegal policy, practice, or custom of discriminating against employees based on their disability or perceived disability, and/or age, and is to be ordered to promulgate an effective policy against such discrimination and to adhere thereto;
• The County shall compensate plaintiff, reimburse plaintiff, and make plaintiff whole for any and all pay and benefits plaintiff would have received had it not been for defendant’s illegal actions, including but not limited to back pay, front pay, salary, pay increases, medical and other benefits, training, promotions, pension, and seniority. Plaintiff should be accorded those benefits illegally withheld from the time the County terminated plaintiff’s employment.
• The County shall pay plaintiff compensatory damages for the pain, suffering, mental anguish and humiliation caused it has caused to plaintiff by its illegal actions as permitted by the Rehab Act and ADA;
• Because the county willfully violated plaintiff’s rights under the ADEA, the County shall pay liquidated damages to plaintiff pursuant to section 626(b) of the ADEA;
• Plaintiff is to be awarded the costs and expenses of this action and reasonable legal fees as provided by applicable federal and state law;
• Plaintiff is to be accorded any and all other equitable and legal relief as the Court deems just, proper, and appropriate, plus a trial by jury.
The plaintiff is represented by Marc E. Weinstein of Weinstein Law Firm, in Fort Washington.
The defendant has not yet secured legal counsel.
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania case 2:20-cv-05803
From the Pennsylvania Record: Reach Courts Reporter Nicholas Malfitano at nick.malfitano@therecordinc.com