PITTSBURGH – One Western Pennsylvania homeowner has filed a class action nuisance lawsuit alleging that U.S. Steel’s refinery plant in Braddock has generated pollutant byproducts, which have affected the quality of life of area residents.
Alissa Finley (on behalf of herself and all others similarly-situated) of West Mifflin filed suit in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas on Nov. 1 versus USX Company (doing business as “U.S. Steel Corporation”) of Braddock.
“The defendant owns, operates and/or controls the steel facility, which is situated on 107 acres of land and surrounded by residential properties. The facility produces steel slabs, which are sent to defendant’s other steel facilities for further processing and refining or to consumers for commercial use. The systems used in manufacturing the steel slabs include blast furnaces, top-blown basic oxygen process vessels, metallurgy furnaces, vacuum degassers and slab casters,” the suit says.
“The byproducts generated by the defendant’s facility operations include the following: Dust; noxious odors and gases; flames, smoke and plumes; ash and soot; slag and iron/metallic particles. The facility has additional dust sources that contribute to the atmospheric particulate burden, such as vehicular traffic on paved and unpaved roads. This traffic consists of plant personnel and visitors, plant service vehicles and trucks hauling raw materials, steel products and waste materials. Materials are also transported by skip cars, bottom railroad dumps, front-end loaders, truck dumps and conveyor transfer stations.”
The suit adds the facility has a track record of previous violations from the Allegheny County Health Department, with numerous Clean Air Act violations necessitating a $1.5 million fine being handed down against the defendant – and that the facility has failed to prevent and control its dangerous emissions.
“The invasion of plaintiff’s property by noxious odors and fugitive dust has interfered with plaintiff’s use and enjoyment of her property, resulting in substantial damages. For purposes of illustration, plaintiff noted that because of the noxious odors and fugitive dust emitted on her property she ‘cannot enjoy our home as we like’ and that some nights she ‘can’t breathe because the odor is so bad.’ Plaintiff’s property has been and continues to be physically invaded by noxious odors and fugitive dust,” the suit states.
“The noxious odors and fugitive dust which entered plaintiff’s property originated from the facility, where both are generated as a result of defendant’s steel production process. A properly-operated, maintained and/or constructed steel plant will not emit noxious odors and fugitive dust into the surrounding residential areas. Defendant’s operation, maintenance, control and/or use of its facility has caused noxious odors and fugitive dust into the surrounding residential areas.”
As part of the putative class, the plaintiff seeks to join forces with any property owners from 2020 to the present located within a one-mile radius of the facility, who have been similarly-affected.
For counts of negligence, gross negligence, private nuisance, public nuisance and trespass by fugitive dust, the plaintiff is seeking compensatory damages, injunctive relief outside of that required by federal and state-issued air permits, punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, such further relief and a trial by jury.
The plaintiff is represented by James E. DePasquale in Pittsburgh, plus Steven D. Liddle, Nicholas A. Coulson and Matt Z. Robb of Liddle Sheets Coulson in Detroit, Mich.
The defendant has not yet obtained legal counsel.
Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas case GD-22-013483
From the Pennsylvania Record: Reach Courts Reporter Nicholas Malfitano at nick.malfitano@therecordinc.com