PITTSBURGH – The Community College of Allegheny County counters that a Pittsburgh woman is responsible for her own injuries, when she fell due to the presence of a gardening border which protruded from the ground along a sidewalk on its campus.
Yugonda Moore of Pittsburgh first filed suit in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas on Nov. 19 versus Community College of Allegheny County, also of Pittsburgh.
“On April 8, 2019, while walking on the sidewalk adjacent to the Leroy Ewing Building, the plaintiff was caused to fall as a result of the dangerous and hazardous condition of the gardening border which was protruding from the ground along the sidewalk, which condition the defendant had allowed to exist for an extended period of time, which caused the plaintiff to be thrown to the ground with such force and violence as to cause the injuries to the plaintiff,” the suit stated.
“The accident and the injuries and damages resulting therefrom were caused by the careless and negligent conduct of the defendant in failing to provide a safe walking area for invitees, and in permitting a hazardous condition to exist on the sidewalk, specifically the gardening border, over an extended period of time, when the defendant knew or should have known, that the condition of the gardening border constituted a hazard.”
Among other rationales, the suit further outlined Moore’s injuries and damages, allegedly caused by the school’s negligent conduct.
“As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of the defendant, Moore suffered a right wrist sprain, right knee sprain, right ankle sprain and right shoulder pain, as well as the muscles, ligaments, tissues, tendons, nerves and bones in, about and extending from these portions of the plaintiff’s body as well, all of which are injuries that are or may be serious and permanent,” according to the suit.
“Moore has experienced and endured pain, suffering, inconvenience, irritation, annoyance, fright, shock, worry, humiliation, anxiety and other forms of distress.”
UPDATE
The Community College of Allegheny County and its counsel filed an answer to the complaint with new matter on Dec. 11, denying Moore’s allegations, any and all liability and demanding judgment in its favor and against the plaintiff.
In new matter, the school counters that Moore caused her own fall.
“The claims are barred, circumscribed or otherwise diminished by the contributory and/or comparative negligence of the plaintiff. Although not necessary to do so, defendant pleads the affirmative defenses of comparative negligence, contributory negligence and assumption of the risk as a full and complete bar to plaintiff’s claims against defendant,” the answer stated, in part.
“Plaintiff’s alleged injuries and damages, if any, were caused by acts or omissions plaintiff and/or a third party or parties for whose conduct defendant is neither liable nor responsible, for which plaintiff’s alleged injuries and damages against defendant are barred. Plaintiff’s alleged injuries and damages, if any, were caused by intervening and/or superseding causes not within the control of defendant. Plaintiff’s alleged damages, if any, were caused by the careless and negligent conduct of the plaintiff.”
The school additionally claimed it is immune from suit under the Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act and that, as a student of the institution, Moore should have been familiar with the grounds and aware of any hazardous conditions therein, if applicable.
“Plaintiff’s alleged injuries and damages, if any, and which are specifically denied, were caused by plaintiff’s voluntarily choosing to step off of the sidewalk and walk across/through/upon the area where mulch existed, when the area was open and obvious, and as such, plaintiff failed to take the appropriate/alternative route, if any dangerous condition existed thereon as alleged by plaintiff,” the answer said.
For a count of negligence, the plaintiff is seeking compensatory and consequential damages in excess of the jurisdictional arbitration limits, plus interest, costs and any other relief this Court deems appropriate to recover.
The plaintiff is represented by Mark D. Troyan of Robert Peirce & Associates, in Pittsburgh.
The defendant is represented by Francis D. Wymard of William J. Ferren & Associates, in Hartford, Conn.
Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas case GD-20-011900
From the Pennsylvania Record: Reach Courts Reporter Nicholas Malfitano at nick.malfitano@therecordinc.com